Red and White One For All: Animated Film Worth Rp6.7 Billion Sparks Wave of Criticism

Source: source/ilustrasi jejaknesia.com

www.jejaknesia.com – Like the opening chapter of a patriotic adventure novel, the animated film Merah Putih One For All opens the curtain with an inspiring tone: eight children from diverse cultures unite on a mission to save the lost national flag. Yet, as the story unfolds, echoes of criticism roar loudly across the digital world.

The Story Behind the Budget & Criticism

Extravagant Budget by Local Standards

It was revealed that the film was produced with a budget of approximately Rp 6.7 billion within a very short period—around 1–2 months—according to reports from various parties and executive producer Sonny Pudjisasono.

Visuals Deemed Inadequate

Instead of awe, the trailer sparked controversy: the animated visuals were considered stiff, lacking expression, even resembling PlayStation 2 games or school assignments. Some sharp critiques viewed the animation as “spectacular from a budget perspective, not from quality.”

Transparency Issues & Professional Critiques

The public questioned transparency: character and background assets were reportedly purchased for a few dollars, yet billions of rupiah were spent. Previous animated film creator Ryan Adriandhy (director of “Jumbo”) also indirectly criticized the production quality of this film.

National Values That Continue to Fly High

Amid the flood of criticism, the film still carries a message of national unity—through eight children of different ethnicities working together to save a symbol of independence. Though somewhat clichéd, the narrative carries a noble intention to awaken patriotic spirit.

Watch the Trailer Now

Closing Remarks

Like the opening chapter of a long story, Merah Putih One For All reminds us that good intentions can spread—but quality is the true catalyst to ensure those intentions are remembered and appreciated. Hopefully, this critique becomes a foundation for the Indonesian animation industry to grow more mature, creative, and transparent.

References:

• Detik.com
• CNN Indonesia
• MetroTV News
• Lombok Post
• Suara.com
• Brilio.net
• Detik Bali
• Wikipedia Indonesia
• Medcom.id